Partner Selection:

Establishing Best-in-Class Marketing Analytics Capability to Achieve 15-30% ROI Uplift

Executive Summary

For a leading online food delivery business investing over $50m annually in marketing, Working Media Partners led a transformative vendor selection process that revolutionised their marketing analytics capabilities. The client needed to maximise the value of their marketing analytics investment to improve performance and drive more effective budget allocation. While their existing measurement methodologies provided some insight, there was a clear need for a more comprehensive approach that would integrate both long-term and short-term Marketing Mix Modelling (MMM) into their measurement framework.

This Transformation Led to:

15-30% ROI Improvement Through Optimised Budget Allocation

Comprehensive Мeasurement Framework Covering Both Short and Long-term Impacts

Enhanced Stakeholder Alignment Across Five Departments

Streamlined Implementation Process Completed Within Four Months

Our Approach:

The project consisted of three distinct phases: defining requirements through stakeholder engagement; assessing and segmenting the analytics market; and comprehensive evaluation of vendor approach and capabilities in relation to our brief.

1.Stakeholder Engagement

Our first critical step was to identify and understand the measurement needs across the organisation. We conducted extensive interviews with over 30 stakeholders spanning five departments, including brand marketing, performance marketing, and finance. This comprehensive engagement process was essential to ensure that the integration of MMM into their measurement framework would meet diverse needs and maximise business value.

Through these detailed stakeholder interviews, we uncovered several crucial unanswered questions that needed addressing:

  • Determining optimum budget allocation
  • Understanding the key drivers of brand equity
  • Balancing long-term versus short-term effects
  • Predicting performance against business KPIs

This discovery phase led to the identification of the need for an advanced MMM solution capable of answering key business questions and enabling stakeholders to make informed investment decisions aligned with business objectives. We developed a detailed brief to align internal teams and guide external vendors, ensuring the solution would comprehensively meet all business needs.

Why Every Marketer Needs a Custom Measurement Framework

2. Market Assessment

Our market analysis revealed a diverse landscape of econometrics vendors, each offering distinct capabilities, methodologies, and price points suited to different organisational needs. We conducted a thorough assessment of four key vendor categories:

Boutique Providers

These specialised vendors offer tailored econometric modelling with niche expertise and flexible approaches, ideal for focused measurement needs. Their strengths include customised insights, competitive pricing, and personalised attention. However, limitations in scalability and data infrastructure make them less suitable for large-scale, cross-market initiatives. They excel at delivering high-touch solutions for targeted analytics requirements.

Mid-Sized Challengers

Mid-sized challengers offer a balanced mix of flexibility, sophistication, and cost efficiency. They excel in customisation, advanced methodologies, and cross-department insights. While less scalable than global providers, they are ideal for delivering actionable insights across departments at a competitive price.

Global Giants

Global giants provide comprehensive solutions for complex, large-scale needs with advanced methodologies like unobserved component modelling. They deliver precise insights for organisations with significant media investments, supporting both short-term activation and long-term brand growth, but can incur higher fees and longer timelines. In some cases the need to service multiple clients means modelling solutions are less customisable to an individual advertiser’s specific needs.

Media Agency Divisions

Media agency divisions integrate econometrics with media planning and buying, enabling seamless strategy execution and quick adjustments. They excel in short-term performance metrics but often prioritise immediate results over long-term brand-building, making them less suitable for comprehensive measurement needs. Additionally, agencies profit from their clients’ investment with preferred suppliers, and this can undermine confidence in MMM integrity.

3. Vendor Evaluation Approach

Comprehensive Evaluation Framework

The vendor evaluation process was meticulously designed to provide an exhaustive comparison of each provider’s econometric capabilities, with particular emphasis on their approaches to capturing long-term brand impact alongside short-term sales activation. This became especially crucial in today’s cookie-independent landscape, where precise, holistic measurement is increasingly vital for informed decision-making and accurate attribution.

We structured our evaluation around four key criteria, each systematically scored using tailored scorecards to document the unique strengths and limitations of each vendor in relation to the client’s objectives. A cross-functional “pitch team” was formed, bringing together representatives from marketing, finance, and insight & analytics to ensure diverse input and complete alignment with the client’s priorities.

Detailed Evaluation Criteria

1. Modelling Rigour and Methodology

Our examination of statistical models focused on their robustness and capability to attribute sales accurately while providing reliable predictions of both short- and long-term marketing effects. The evaluation considered:

  • Statistical validity and theoretical foundation
  • Attribution methodology sophistication
  • Predictive accuracy and reliability
  • Ability to separate short-term and long-term effects
  • Integration of multiple data sources
  • Treatment of interaction effects
  • Handling of diminishing returns
  • Base sales calculation approaches

 

Vendors were scored based on their ability to support both immediate campaign performance measurement and sustained brand growth tracking, with particular attention paid to the sophistication of their analytical approaches.

2. Depth of Insights and Long-Term Measurement

The assessment of long-term modelling capabilities ranged from basic multiplier techniques to advanced unobserved component methods. Key evaluation points included:

  • Methodology for isolating long-term brand effects
  • Treatment of base sales and brand equity
  • Integration of brand tracking metrics
  • Cross-channel attribution capabilities
  • Granularity of insights
  • Ability to account for market context
  • Quality of strategic recommendations
  • Innovation in measurement approaches

 

Each vendor’s approach was evaluated for its ability to segment long-term brand effects from short-term impacts, enabling detailed, actionable insights for the client’s strategic needs.

3. Consultative Support and Guidance

Understanding that effective MMM requires both technical expertise and interpretive insight, we evaluated vendors on:

  • Quality and clarity of insight communication
  • Strategic recommendation development
  • Implementation support capabilities
  • Stakeholder management approach
  • Training and knowledge transfer
  • Ongoing support structure
  • Response time and accessibility
  • Team expertise and experience

 

Vendors demonstrating superior ability to communicate findings clearly and provide strategic recommendations for brand-building scored more highly, as they could directly support the client’s organisational goals.

4. Cost, Efficiency, and Pricing Comparability

A standardised costing framework was developed to ensure fair comparison across vendors. Each provider submitted detailed proposals based on specific project requirements, allowing for equitable cost comparison. Evaluation factors included:

  • Total cost of ownership
  • Resource allocation efficiency
  • Automation capabilities
  • AI integration potential
  • Human support levels
  • Implementation timeline
  • Ongoing maintenance costs
  • Scalability costs

Implementation Challenges and Solutions

Proactive Challenge Management

The implementation of a robust Marketing Mix Modelling (MMM) project typically faces several significant challenges that require careful planning and proactive management. We identified and addressed key challenges:

1. Data Quality and Integration

Challenge: Obtaining high-quality data presented a primary hurdle, as the model’s robustness depends heavily on including comprehensive relevant variables. Media data often misaligned with campaign dates, generating numerous queries from econometricians working to establish consistency.

Solution:

  • Standardised data collection protocols
  • Clear data quality requirements
  • Streamlined submission processes
  • Proactive query management systems
  • Regular data quality audits
  • Automated validation checks
  • Comprehensive data documentation

2. Stakeholder Management

Challenge: Managing expectations across diverse stakeholders presented significant complexity, as extensive wishlists of requirements needed careful prioritisation and management.

Solution:

  • Clear prioritisation framework for deliverables
  • Structured roadmap for addressing additional questions
  • Regular stakeholder communication channels
  • Expectation management protocols
  • Progress tracking systems
  • Clear escalation paths
  • Regular review sessions

3. Tool Optimisation

Challenge: Ensuring optimisation and scenario planning tools remained user-friendly and intuitive while maintaining analytical rigour.

Solution:

  • Intuitive user interfaces
  • Standardised output formats
  • Clear documentation
  • Training programmes
  • User support systems
  • Regular feedback loops
  • Continuous improvement processes

Results and Impact

Quantifiable Outcomes

The implementation of our advanced MMM solution delivered significant improvements across multiple areas:

Performance Improvements

  • ROI uplifts of 15% to 30% through optimised budget allocation
  • Enhanced channel performance through strategic reallocation
  • Improved long-term brand metrics
  • Better prediction accuracy for campaign performance
  • Increased marketing efficiency across channels

Operational Benefits

  • Streamlined data collection and analysis processes
  • Enhanced stakeholder alignment and buy-in
  • Improved decision-making speed and accuracy
  • More efficient resource allocation
  • Better cross-department collaboration

Strategic Impact

The project delivered several key strategic benefits:

1.Enhanced Decision-Making Capability

  • Data-driven budget allocation processes
  • Improved long-term planning capability
  • Better understanding of channel interactions
  • More accurate performance predictions
  • Enhanced risk management
  •  

2.Operational Excellence

  • Streamlined workflows and processes
  • Clear governance structures
  • Efficient stakeholder management
  • Rapid implementation capabilities
  • Better resource utilisation
  •  

3.Future-Proofing

  • Scalable measurement framework
  • Cookie-independent solution
  • Flexible adaptation capabilities
  • Innovation readiness
  • Enhanced competitive advantage

Let’s Talk about Better Working Media!

Book a discovery call to discuss how we can help maximise your investment performance